Published On: Sat, Jun 2nd, 2012

Great Examples of How NOT to Run Blogger Outreach Programs

How Not to Outreach to BloggersOver the last couple of months I’ve received several guest blog post proposals; some have been great, most have been less so. The latter are the subject of this post.

To be clear I do not actively seek out guest posts. Instead, I am happy to receive suggestions, and try to judge each case based on its own merit. Indeed, when a PR or SEO gets in touch with an interesting, valuable and ultimately beneficial proposal it often results in a blog post. That’s how things should work. For reference, my preferred modus operandi is to hold a Q&A with an industry expert, thought-leader or somebody with an interesting story to tell. But that’s beside the point.

What has frustrated me and needs to be addressed is the number of weak outreach proposals I’ve received. These have been mostly from SEO agencies and lets be honest, they are nothing more than link-building tactics, thinly veiled as an opportunity for ‘unique’ and ‘quality’ content.

My good friend Chris Norton of Dead Dinosaur PR recently wrote about the impact of Google Penguin on cheaper SEO companies and it seems, whilst some SEO agencies are doing a fantastic job, creating meaningful relationships with bloggers and providing great content, many are not.

I have written about constructing and adding value to an outreach proposition, in short offering something that is mutually beneficial, but also of enough perceived value to the blogger so they are enticed to act. This is a concept that is all to often missing from outreach.

To illustrate the point, below are a selection of emails I’ve been sent. The first two did not mention what the proposed posts would be on, give the author’s credentials or even show links to previous blog posts. Without these crucial details, it is impossible to calculate the proposed value exchange.

 

 

 

 

 

Whilst, the third email was slightly more enticing and engaging, it was poorly written. The SEO guy offered me an article about using social media to find a job, which would certainly been of interest. Maybe this person had a fantastic story about using social media to land the job of his dreams, but it was unclear. The outreach lacked context and value, and after follow-up discussion, the search executive even denied the posts were written for link-building purposes, which I find hard to believe. If you can’t be honest and establish trust, there’s no way you can build a working relationship.

 

 

 

 

 

 

The key point from all three examples is that without communicating credentials or proof of competency, I have no idea who this person is. Without this they are just a name, and lacking in credibility, trust and authority – and subsequently the outreach proposition becomes much less valuable.

Ironically, if these SEO guys wanted to give their outreach proposal a greater chance of succeeding, they should have looked a lot closer to home and suggested a post on SEO. They work in that discipline, I mention ‘search’ amongst my interests and even have a blog category dedicated to it.

What’s your view on these outreach emails? Am I being too pernickety? How can we drive up standards?

About the Author

-

Marketing Manager with a passion for inbound at HubSpot, Founder of Growth Hack Talks, Blogger at Ben-Cotton.com and Chief Quaffer at CraftySwine.org .

Displaying 3 Comments
Have Your Say
  1. Pete Stean says:

    Ben, as you may know I don’t operate in your space, but the London blogging scene is rife with this stuff. 9 times out of 10, or perhaps 19 times out of 20 if I’m being brutally honest, the proposals I receive offer a great deal more to the client than they do to me, and you’re correct in that many of them are thinly veiled link-building schemes.

    The main annoyance I have is that most of these link-builders are very cagey and can sometimes be difficult to spot straight away. Thus, I had an exchange last week that took until the third email from them to determine that what they wanted was a link in a post, and at that point they still hadn’t revealed who their client was! Needless to say this was a complete waste of my time and theirs because I don’t post material like that….

    • Ben says:

      Hey Pete,

      Great to hear from you and sorry for the slow reply.

      Since I wrote this post I’ve received two more emails from charlatan SEO companies. I can’t decide if these people are arrogant or just plain stupid, with the ridiculously vague offer of ‘unique’ content

      One thing I’m certain of is: these time-wasters operate on the margins of the SEO industry and do not reflect the excellent work many search specialists do.

      Thanks,

      Ben

  2. […] He’s sharing some examples of guest blog post proposals that didn’t work as planned. Check out Great Examples of How NOT to Run Blogger Outreach Programs and learn what to do when sending blog post […]

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these html tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Subscribe to SWT


Most Popular Posts

Follow

Get every new post on this blog delivered to your Inbox.

Join other followers:

n/a